A ceramic bowl mended with gold along its cracks, in warm light.
AI-generated image

ResilienceStories and mindset

Rejected, Doubted, Undeterred: 3 Physicians Who Turned Setbacks Into Breakthroughs

Elizabeth Blackwell, Charles Drew and Paul Farmer faced rejection and doubt. Their stories, the move each one teaches, and the setback rules students miss.

Contents
  1. 1. Elizabeth Blackwell: one yes was enough
  2. 2. Charles Drew: he walked away rather than accept bad science
  3. 3. Paul Farmer: he treated his critics' doubts as a design brief
  4. The rules that matter in your first week after a setback
  5. What the three stories have in common

Elizabeth Blackwell was turned down by school after school, 29 by one count, before Geneva Medical College accepted her in 1847. Two years later she graduated at the head of her class, the first woman to earn a medical degree in the United States.

If a rejection letter, a failed exam or a doubting attending has you questioning whether you belong in medicine, these three physicians faced worse. Each story below ends with a move you can make this week, followed by the little-known rules that matter if your setback is a failed USMLE, an unmatched Monday or a dismissal.

1. Elizabeth Blackwell: one yes was enough

When Blackwell applied to medical school in 1847, accounts differ on how many schools refused her; Hobart and William Smith Colleges puts it at 29 (HWS). In October 1847 Geneva Medical College in upstate New York accepted her, though she still had to fight for access to a full education (National Park Service).

She graduated on January 23, 1849, first in her class (HWS; Embryo Project Encyclopedia).

The move: widen the funnel, because you only need one door. The modern version is SOAP. In 2026, unmatched and partially matched applicants filled 2,632 residency positions during Match Week alone, according to the NRMP's 2026 Results and Data report. If you might need it, write your backup-specialty personal statements before March, not on the Monday you find out.

2. Charles Drew: he walked away rather than accept bad science

Drew's research on storing blood made him the leading U.S. authority on transfusion. He directed the Blood for Britain project, which separated plasma, tested it and shipped it overseas, and in 1941 became director of the first American Red Cross blood bank (National Archives).

When the Red Cross adopted the military's policy of segregating blood by the donor's race, Drew denounced it on moral and scientific grounds and resigned (NewYork-Presbyterian; National WWII Museum).

The move: decide your line before the pressure arrives. Write down the one principle you will not trade on rotations, and the person you would call if you were asked to cross it: an adviser, a dean or your school's ombudsperson. Drew's resignation cost him a post, not his reputation.

3. Paul Farmer: he treated his critics' doubts as a design brief

Farmer co-founded Partners In Health in 1987 (NIH Record). For years, many international health experts believed effective AIDS treatment was impossible in the poorest countries. Farmer's community-based approach, with health workers supporting patients every day, was also used against multidrug-resistant tuberculosis in Peru and in Russian prisons (Heinz Awards).

In the slums of Lima, the program reported an 83.3% success rate against multidrug-resistant TB (Yale Medicine). In 1999 the World Health Organization asked Farmer and his colleague Jim Yong Kim to launch international programs to treat it (Britannica). Farmer died in Rwanda in February 2022, at 62.

The move: turn the verdict into data. If your setback is a failed USMLE, the data are already in your hands. A failing score report breaks your performance down by physician task, organ system and discipline, and compares each area with examinees who only just passed, not with the average, as the USMLE's sample failing report shows. It says the profile can guide future study, and it also recommends reviewing all content areas because the exam is integrative. Rank your three weakest areas and build your first two weeks around them.

The rules that matter in your first week after a setback

Setback rules worth knowing early. Check the official source for your exam, cycle or school.
SetbackThe rule many students learn too lateYour first move
Failed a USMLE StepYou get at most four attempts at a Step, counting incomplete attempts, and no more than three in 12 months. A fourth attempt must come at least 12 months after your first and six months after your most recent (USMLE).Pull your performance profile and map your weakest areas before you book a new date.
Didn't matchSOAP for the 2027 Match opens at 10 a.m. ET on Monday, March 15, and you may not contact a SOAP program until it contacts you.Read the SOAP 2027 Match Week guide now, before you need it.
Failed a course or shelfStart with diagnosis, not more hours: find out which question types and topics you missed.Run the 90-minute exam autopsy.
Facing dismissalAppeal windows are set by your school's own policy and can be short.Find the deadline in your handbook today and follow the 14-day comeback plan.

If your practice scores have stalled instead, our 14-day NBME plateau plan walks through what to change.

What the three stories have in common

  • None of them waited for the setback to make sense. Blackwell kept applying, Drew acted on his objection instead of going along, and Farmer built the program his critics said could not work.
  • Each turned the verdict into a next step. A rejection became a wider search, a bad policy became a resignation on the record, and doubt became a design problem.
  • Their reputations rest on what came after. The rejections are remembered only as the prelude.

A setback is a data point with a deadline attached. Find the deadline first, then use the data.

MedRise Resilience offers perspective and encouragement. It is not medical, legal or mental health advice.

Came back from a setback of your own? Your story could help the next person.

Write it up for MedRise Perspectives: 600 to 1,200 words, published under your name, with a decision usually within one day.

Book a free strategy call

Ten minutes to look at your exam date, your scores and what is getting in the way.