Contents
America's two best-known television doctors now hold very different jobs. Sanjay Gupta, a practicing neurosurgeon, is still CNN's chief medical correspondent. Mehmet Oz, a heart surgeon who hosted a daytime show from 2009 to 2022, has run Medicare and Medicaid since the Senate confirmed him 53-45 on April 3, 2025.
Their paths matter to anyone in medicine because public trust in doctors is falling, and television doctors are the most visible test of it. A 50-state survey of more than 443,000 U.S. adults found trust in physicians and hospitals fell from 71.5% in April 2020 to 40.1% in January 2024, and people with lower trust were less likely to get vaccinated.
The American Medical Association has written rules for exactly this situation. Read against those rules, the two careers show what keeps trust and what spends it, for a famous surgeon on cable or a resident posting a 60-second video.
Americans still trust their own doctor most
The decline is not uniform. In an Annenberg Public Policy Center survey of 1,904 adults fielded August 4 to 17, 2026, 87% said they were confident their own doctor, nurse or primary care provider gives trustworthy public health information, statistically unchanged from 88% in September 2024. Confidence in the FDA fell to 59% from 73% over the same period, and confidence in the NIH to 61% from 74%, CIDRAP reported.
Doctors feel the pressure anyway. In the Physicians Foundation's 2026 survey of 1,002 physicians, 65% said medical misinformation is significantly affecting their ability to provide quality care, up from 57% a year earlier, Medical Economics reported.
The pattern is the point: people trust the clinician they know far more than distant institutions. A TV doctor sits in between, a stranger who borrows the trust people give their own physician.
Gupta's habit: changing his mind in public
Gupta has reported for CNN since 2001 while continuing to operate, according to his National Academy of Medicine profile. His best-known moment came in August 2013, when he wrote "Why I changed my mind on weed" while making a documentary on medical marijuana. He had argued against it in 2009; after reviewing more research and meeting patients, he reversed himself, CBS News reported, writing that he was "here to apologize."
The dual role has drawn criticism too. After the 2015 Nepal earthquake, where he both reported and operated, a factual error in CNN's coverage led NPR to examine the tension between his roles as surgeon and correspondent.
At the American Psychiatric Association's 2026 annual meeting, he described his aim as promoting empathy through clarity, Psychiatric News reported. Whatever viewers think of his conclusions, his method is visible: show the evidence, say when it changed, and say when you were wrong.
Oz's record: a show tested by evidence reviewers, then a federal agency
In 2014, researchers at the University of Alberta tested what daytime medical talk shows tell viewers. Reviewers searched for evidence behind 80 randomly chosen recommendations from each of two shows. For The Dr Oz Show, evidence supported 46%, contradicted 15% and was not found for 39%, the BMJ study reported. For The Doctors, the figures were 63%, 14% and 24%.
The same year, a Senate consumer protection subcommittee questioned Oz about weight-loss supplements promoted on his show, including green coffee bean extract. He acknowledged his language had been "flowery" and promised to publish a list of products he thought could help, the Associated Press reported.
His appointment to lead CMS, which covers more than 160 million people, divided physicians and policy experts. Georgetown health law professor Lawrence Gostin called him "unfit," NPR reported. Senate Finance Committee Chair Mike Crapo spoke approvingly of his plans to modernize the agency and tackle chronic disease, according to Fierce Healthcare. At his hearing, Oz said a physician has a responsibility to tell patients what they need to know even when it is uncomfortable, BenefitsPRO reported. In his first statement as administrator, CMS said he would shift the system toward prevention, wellness and chronic disease management.
The AMA's rules for doctors on camera
The AMA adopted Code of Medical Ethics Opinion 8.12 in 2017. It tells physicians in the media to:
- Remember they are physicians first, bound by the profession's values, not entertainers or commentators.
- Give information that is accurate, conveys known risks and benefits, rests on valid scientific evidence and stays within their expertise.
- Fully disclose conflicts of interest and avoid situations that create them.
- Recognize that viewers may treat general advice as personal medical advice.
The AMA also tells physicians not to offer diagnoses of people they have not examined, such as public officials or celebrities, it says in its guidance. That rule applies every time a doctor is asked on air about a politician's health.
What it means for you
Medical students and residents are now media figures by default: a TikTok explainer, a LinkedIn post or a podcast clip can reach thousands of strangers who will never meet you. Five habits from the evidence:
- Run the one-hour test. The BMJ reviewers gave themselves about an hour to find evidence for each claim. Before you post a recommendation, can you find a guideline, trial or review that supports it in that time? If not, say it is your opinion or leave it out.
- Name the size of the effect. The same study found TV recommendations often lacked specifics on how big the benefit was. "Lowers risk" is weak; "cuts risk by about a third in this trial" is checkable.
- Disclose money before you are asked. Supplements, sponsors and affiliate links are where on-camera trust breaks fastest, and Opinion 8.12 requires disclosure.
- Correct yourself out loud. Gupta's 2013 reversal is still cited because he showed what changed his mind. A dated correction builds more trust than a quiet edit. MedRise does the same in its editorial standards.
- Use the trust you already have. The 87% figure is about people's own clinicians. Your strongest platform is the patient in front of you, which is why vaccine conversations during outbreaks like the return of endemic measles matter most in the exam room.
What to watch next
Annenberg repeats its trust survey in waves, so the next release will show whether the gap between trust in personal clinicians and trust in federal agencies keeps widening. CMS decisions under Oz on Medicare payment and prior authorization will shape how physicians judge his leadership, and that record will matter more than his television years.
The lesson from both careers is the same one residents learn on rounds: say what the evidence shows, say how sure you are, and say so when it changes. Cameras only make the stakes larger.
Want to write for physicians and trainees? Pitch an evidence-based piece through Write for MedRise, or follow the day's stories in MedRise Medical News.
Sources
- Perlis RH et al., Trust in Physicians and Hospitals During the COVID-19 Pandemic in a 50-State Survey of US Adults, JAMA Network Open (July 31, 2024)
- Annenberg Public Policy Center, confidence in health care providers and federal health agencies, topline (August 2026)
- CIDRAP, Annenberg poll: Americans trust their doctors when it comes to public health (2026)
- Medical Economics, Physicians Foundation 2026 survey on misinformation (September 2, 2026)
- National Academy of Medicine, Sanjay Gupta, MD, FACS
- CBS News, Sanjay Gupta backs medical marijuana, apologizes for previous views (August 2013)
- NPR, Sanjay Gupta coverage, including dual-role scrutiny after the 2015 Nepal earthquake
- Psychiatric News, Dr. Sanjay Gupta at the APA 2026 annual meeting (May 17, 2026)
- Korownyk C et al., Televised medical talk shows: what they recommend and the evidence to support their recommendations, BMJ (December 17, 2014)
- Associated Press, Senate hearing on weight-loss advertising (June 17, 2014)
- American Hospital Association, Senate confirms Mehmet Oz as CMS administrator (April 3, 2025)
- NPR, nomination coverage (November 19, 2024)
- Fierce Healthcare, confirmation vote (April 2025)
- BenefitsPRO, confirmation coverage (April 4, 2025)
- CMS, Dr. Mehmet Oz shares vision for CMS (April 10, 2025)
- AMA Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 8.12, Ethical Physician Conduct in the Media
- AMA, When the news media calls, keep these 4 things in mind
MedRise Perspectives analyses are for education only. They are not medical or legal advice, and MedRise has no affiliation with CNN, CMS or the people named.




Comments
Comments are reviewed before they appear. Share your reasoning, your experience or a question for the author. No patient details, no medical advice for individual cases and no links. Comment rules.
Thank you. Your comment was received and will appear after review, usually within a few hours.
Your comment was not sent. Please add your name, a valid email and at least 20 characters, and tick the box.
Links are not allowed in comments. Please remove them and send it again.
You have reached today's comment limit. Please try again tomorrow.
Your comment was not sent because the "Verify you are human" check did not finish. Please tick it and send again.