Policies
Publication ethics and policies
How The Differential handles ethics, conflicts, corrections, AI and independence. Last updated November 15, 2026.
Publication ethics
The Differential follows the Core Practices and guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the ICMJE Recommendations, and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing published by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME. Where a case is not covered here, the editors follow COPE's flowcharts.
Allegations of misconduct
Anyone may raise a concern about a submitted or published article, including fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, image manipulation, undisclosed conflicts, authorship disputes, or ethics and consent failures, by emailing the editorial office. Concerns are handled confidentially and promptly. We ask the authors for an explanation, and where needed we contact their institution, which is responsible for investigating misconduct. Anonymous concerns are considered if they contain enough evidence to check.
Authorship
Authors must meet all four ICMJE authorship criteria, and every contribution is recorded using CRediT. Changes to the author list after submission need a written explanation and the agreement of every author, including anyone removed. Ghost, guest and gift authorship are not allowed. AI tools cannot be authors.
Conflicts of interest
- Authors complete the ICMJE Disclosure Form, and a summary is published with the article.
- Reviewers decline any manuscript where they have a conflict (see the peer review policy).
- Editors declare conflicts each year and step aside from any manuscript where one exists.
- The publisher: MedRise sells medical education products. Articles that evaluate a MedRise product, or are written by MedRise staff, are handled by an editor with no MedRise role and carry a conflict-of-interest statement.
Plagiarism and duplicate publication
Every submission is checked for text overlap with published work before review. Plagiarism, including self-plagiarism of substantial text and duplicate or redundant publication, leads to rejection, or to correction or retraction if found after publication.
Data and reproducibility
Research articles include a data availability statement. We encourage authors to share de-identified data, survey instruments, case materials and analysis code in a public repository, and we may ask for the data during review.
Corrections and retractions
- Correction: for an honest error that does not change the conclusions. Published as a linked correction notice, with the article updated and the change dated.
- Expression of concern: while a serious concern is being investigated.
- Retraction: when the findings are unreliable, because of misconduct or major error, or when the work was plagiarized, duplicated or unethical. Follows COPE's retraction guidelines. The article stays online, clearly marked as retracted, with the reason.
- Published articles are never silently changed.
Complaints and appeals
Complaints about the journal's process, an editor, or a decision go to the editorial office. We acknowledge them within 5 working days and answer within 30. Complaints about the Editor-in-Chief go to the publisher, who refers them to an independent editor. Appeals of editorial decisions follow the appeals process.
AI policy
- Authors: AI cannot be an author; disclose any use beyond spelling and grammar; you are responsible for all content. See instructions for authors.
- Reviewers and editors: never put a manuscript or review into an AI tool. The only AI used on manuscripts is the journal's own pre-review, with the authors' permission.
- The journal's AI pre-review runs on a service that does not train on manuscripts and deletes them within 30 days, produces suggestions only, is given to one of the two reviewers while the other reviews without it, and is overseen by the editors, who audit it yearly. See AI pre-review.
- Images: AI-generated or AI-altered images are not accepted in articles unless they are the subject of the research.
Advertising and editorial independence
The journal carries no advertising, sponsored content or affiliate links. MedRise products are not promoted in journal articles or on journal pages. Commercial interests of the publisher play no part in editorial decisions.
Archiving and preservation
Every published version is kept permanently, and a PDF of each article is deposited in Zenodo. If the journal ever stops publishing, its articles stay freely available.
Privacy
Names and email addresses entered in this journal's forms are used only for the journal's work and are not shared or sold. See the MedRise privacy policy.