Open access · ISSN pendingPublished by MedRise
The DifferentialJournal of Clinical Reasoning

Instructions for authors

Instructions for authors

Everything you need to prepare a manuscript for The Differential. We follow the ICMJE Recommendations for the conduct, reporting, editing and publication of scholarly work in medical journals.

Launch status

The Differential is a new journal. Here is exactly what is in place and what is still coming, so authors and readers can judge it for themselves. Physicians, educators and researchers can apply to join as an editor or reviewer.

  • Editor-in-ChiefComing soonAppointment in progress. A physician editor will lead the journal; names appear only after written acceptance.
  • Editorial boardComing soonRecruiting physicians, educators and researchers. Apply below.
  • ISSNComing soonTo be requested from the U.S. ISSN Center once the inaugural issue is online.
  • DOIsComing soonCrossref DOIs for every article, starting with Volume 1, Issue 1.
  • IndexingComing soonGoogle Scholar tags on every article from the first issue; DOAJ application once the journal meets DOAJ's publishing-history requirement.
  • ArchivingComing soonEvery article PDF deposited in Zenodo on publication.
  • SubmissionsComing soonOpen with the inaugural call for papers.
  • Editorial policiesIn placePublished: peer review, ethics, conflicts of interest, corrections and retractions, AI use, data and advertising.
  • Open access and feesIn placeFree to read under CC BY 4.0. No fees to submit or publish.

Article types

Article typeWhat it isWords (main text)AbstractReview
Original ResearchQuantitative, qualitative or mixed-methods studies of how clinicians and learners reason, and how reasoning is taught and assessed.3,500Structured, 250 words2 peer reviewers
ReviewSystematic, scoping, realist or critical narrative reviews that change how readers think about a reasoning question.4,000Structured or unstructured, 250 words2 peer reviewers
Innovation ReportA new way to teach, coach, remediate or assess clinical reasoning, with evidence of how it worked.2,500Structured, 200 words2 peer reviewers
Reasoning CaseA real case told in stages, with the reasoning at each decision point made visible: what the clinician thought, what changed, what they would do again.2,000Unstructured, 150 words2 peer reviewers
PerspectiveAn argued, referenced position on a live question in clinical reasoning or its teaching.2,000Unstructured, 150 words2 peer reviewers
Point–CounterpointTwo invited authors take opposite sides of one question, then each answers the other in 300 words.1,200 per sideNone2 peer reviewers per pair
LetterA response to an article published in The Differential within the last 6 months.500NoneEditorial review (labeled)
EditorialWritten or invited by the editors. Labeled as an editorial and not peer-reviewed.1,200NoneEditorial review (labeled)

Point–Counterpoint pieces are invited. To propose a debate question and two authors, email the editorial office. Word limits exclude the abstract, tables, figure legends and references. Up to 5 tables or figures for research and reviews, 3 for other types.

Before you submit

  • Fit: read the aims and scope. The question must be about reasoning or how it is taught or assessed.
  • Originality: the work must not be published or under review elsewhere. Preprints are welcome; tell us the preprint's DOI.
  • Authorship: every author must meet all four ICMJE criteria: substantial contribution to the work; drafting or critically revising it; approving the final version; and agreeing to be accountable for it. Others go in the acknowledgments, with their permission.
  • ORCID: the corresponding author needs an ORCID iD; we encourage it for every author.

Preparing the manuscript

  • Files: a title page (separate file), the anonymized manuscript (Word), and each figure as its own file (PNG, TIFF or vector; at least 300 dpi).
  • Title page: title, all authors with degrees, affiliations and ORCID iDs, corresponding author, word count, and the required statements below.
  • Anonymized manuscript: no author names, institutions or identifying acknowledgments, so reviewers judge the work, not the authors. Write "[Institution]" where needed.
  • Abstract and keywords: as in the article-type table, with 3 to 6 keywords, using MeSH terms where they exist.
  • Style: US English, AMA Manual of Style (11th edition), SI units with conventional units in parentheses where useful.
  • References: AMA style, numbered in order of citation. Include DOIs. Cite primary sources, not summaries of them.
  • Tables and figures: each cited in the text, with a legend that stands on its own. Images of patients need written consent (see below).

Reporting guidelines

Follow the guideline that fits your design and upload the completed checklist (from the EQUATOR Network) with your manuscript.

Study typeGuideline
Randomized trialsCONSORT
Observational studiesSTROBE
Qualitative researchSRQR or COREQ
Education and quality-improvement innovationsSQUIRE 2.0 (and SQUIRE-EDU)
Systematic and scoping reviewsPRISMA 2020 or PRISMA-ScR
Narrative reviewsSANRA
Case reports and Reasoning CasesCARE
SurveysCHERRIES (online) or CROSS
Studies of AI toolsTRIPOD+AI, CONSORT-AI or DECIDE-AI, as fits
Assessment and psychometric studiesStandards for Educational and Psychological Testing (validity evidence)

Ethics and consent

  • Research with people, including learners, faculty and patients, needs approval from an institutional review board or ethics committee, or a formal exemption. Name the board and give the approval or exemption number. Educational research is research: survey and assessment data from your own learners count.
  • Learners as participants: explain how you protected learners from pressure to take part, for example by having someone outside their evaluation chain collect consent.
  • Reasoning Cases and case reports need the patient's written consent to publication (or the legal guardian's or next of kin's), on the journal's form or your institution's. Remove every identifier: names, initials, dates, record numbers, places and rare details that could identify the patient. Consent forms stay with the editorial office and are never published.

Required statements

Put these at the end of the title page. Each is published with the article.

  • Author contributions using the CRediT taxonomy (for example: conceptualization, methodology, formal analysis, writing – original draft).
  • Conflicts of interest: each author completes the ICMJE Disclosure Form. Summarize it as a statement, or write "The authors report no conflicts of interest."
  • Funding: every source, with grant numbers, and the funder's role in the work, or "None."
  • Ethics approval and consent statements, as above.
  • Data availability: where the data can be found, or why they cannot be shared and how a reader can request them.
  • Use of AI: see the next section.
  • Prior presentation: any conference abstract or preprint of this work.

Use of AI

  • AI tools cannot be authors. People are responsible for every word, figure and reference.
  • Disclose any use of AI beyond spelling and grammar: which tool and version, what you used it for, and how you checked its output. In the methods if it was part of the research; in the acknowledgments if it helped with writing.
  • Do not use AI to create or alter images or data, unless that is the subject of the research and is described in the methods.
  • Our own AI pre-review is explained in the peer review policy. You choose at submission whether to allow it.

Submission checklist

  • Title page with all authors, affiliations, ORCID iDs, word count and required statements
  • Anonymized manuscript within the word limit for its type
  • Completed reporting-guideline checklist
  • ICMJE Disclosure Form from each author
  • Ethics approval or exemption, and patient consent for any case
  • Cover letter: why the work matters to readers of The Differential, and up to 3 suggested and any opposed reviewers (no recent co-authors or colleagues at your institution)

After acceptance

Accepted articles are copyedited; the corresponding author approves the proofs, usually within 48 hours. The article is published under CC BY 4.0 with its received, accepted and published dates. There is no charge at any stage. Corrections after publication follow our corrections policy.

Submission status